What is more important to you – Commitment or Personal Happiness?

I was talking to my brother in law earlier today, and we were talking about the fun filled topic of divorce.  I mentioned how sometimes it feels like the legal system penalizes people for doing the right thing, and he made a comment about how the right thing is actually subjective.

I asked him what he meant, and he said:

It comes down to your core values.

If your core values tell you commitment is more important than personal happiness, then you are more likely to stay and work on a relationship that is struggling.

If your core values tell you personal happiness is more important, then a struggling relationship means it’s time to move on.

Divorce can be a bad thing or a good thing, it just depends on your core values.


This really hit me.

For years now, I’ve been writing about relationships.  And from the beginning, one of my main premises has been that one of the fundamental struggles in relationships is finding a balance between “me” and “we”.

There has to be a balance between these.


Too much “we” and you risk losing sight of who you are.  And this is often a big issue, especially with parents.

I’ve talked to so many people who have kids and then put their own interests on the backburner.  Life becomes all about the family, and there is very little time/opportunity to be “you”.  As much as people love their children, when the kids get a bit older there is often a of sense of relief when people are able to start doing some things for themselves again.  Of course this is a prime time for divorce, because if there has been too much focus on the family and not enough on the couple, this is a time that a husband and wife will look at each other and realize they don’t really have anything in common anymore.  They have the kids, and that’s it.  Some are able to rediscover each other and “fall in love” all over again, while others just decide it’s better to move on separately.


On the other side of the equation you have couples who focus too much on “me”.  When they do this, they are often two people living completely separate lives, and their relationship is more like being roommates – living under the same roof and sharing bills.


I have always subscribed to the notion that although a balance between “me” and “we” is important, for a healthy relationship it is always better to have the pendulum swing slightly towards “we”.  To me, relationships are all about connection between two people.  That connection ideally will exist on many levels; physical, emotional, intellectual and even spiritual.  And I don’t really see how this connection can happen when your focus is on yourself first.

For me, my core values have always told me that “we” is more important that “me”. 

Don’t misunderstand this, I’m not suggesting that “I” am not important in a relationship, because I clearly am.  But the notion of sacrifice for the relationships has never really been a challenge for me.  It’s never been a struggle, because it simply fit with what I believed.

Due to this, when I would see people who were focused more on themselves and what they get out of thing, I have never been able to understand it.  It just seems selfish to me, and really, it is.

To me, selfish is wrong.  It’s the wrong way to be, and the wrong way to live life.

Here’s the thing though, one of my other beliefs about relationships is that often there are different approaches to doing the same thing, and one isn’t necessarily any better or worse than the other.  My way is just my way, and part of having a healthy relationship is learning to understand and accept your partner for who they are.  To accept their way as valid, even if it’s not my own.


This is where today’s conversation really hit me.  Maybe I’ve been a hypocrite here.  Maybe what I consider selfish isn’t really wrong.  Maybe it’s just different, and wrong for me.  Maybe it’s just a difference in core values.


If so, then maybe a lot of the struggles people have in relationships are actually simply a collision of core values.

I’ve always believed that conflict between couples is actually a positive thing, because it’s how you learn each other and are able to grow to understand and accept each other.

I still think that’s true, but when the conflict is due to a collision of core values?  Well, in that case a couple probably is in quite a bit of trouble.  Because while you can often accept differences between people, differences in core values are significantly more problematic.


Commitment and personal happiness are two concepts that should both be important in a relationship, but they are also concepts that can sometimes conflict.  So the question becomes, when it comes to core values which one is actually MORE important to you?

Because answering that question for yourself and then understanding how your partner would answer that question may have a lot to do with the nature of the conflicts you face.


7 thoughts on “What is more important to you – Commitment or Personal Happiness?

  1. I just asked my husband what’s more important to him and he told me those two are different things. As I read further, I told him it’s the ‘we’ vs ‘me’. And he says well, it’s the ‘we’ then! I asked myself the same question, I came to the conclusion that there will never be ‘we’ if the ‘me’ is broken.

    Liked by 3 people

  2. I think there needs to be a balance between the ‘we’ and the ‘me’. One of the problems I think my marriage had was imbalance; I was more focused on us; he was more focused on himself. Now do I agree with you that focusing on ‘me’ and ignoring the ‘we’ is selfish? Yes. And I’m not saying that had I focused a little more on myself and he a little more on us that we would still be married. (The times I tried to focus on myself rather than what he perceived was best for ‘us’ didn’t go over well, probably because they seemed unlike my usual response.) But I do think if we had both been a little more balanced in our approach to the relationship, things would at least have been different.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I agree, balance is the key – and I hope I conveyed that in the post.

      I think everything is on a spectrum though. Imagine a scale of one to ten let’s say, where “we” is on one side and “me” is on the other. Balance may be the center (5), and that’s an ideal. But realistically, we all lean one way or another.

      I’m a “we” person. But hopefully I’m fairly close to center. Other people are “me” people, but they can still be close to center.

      An issue is, when problems arise we all seem to push a little bit more towards the extreme end of our spectrum.

      Me people pull away, and want time to themselves. We people feel threatened by this isolation, and as their partner starts to pull away they start to chase and get a bit clingy (making things worse).

      We and me are both important, but balance is needed to have a healthy relationship.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. It is a good question and both are important to me. Commitment to my family and my personal happiness. But sometimes, the commitment is taking more of the space than my personal happiness. It is a dilemma that it’s hard to choose. 😦

    Liked by 1 person

    • For me personal happiness is important. But at the same time, I believe that my life is not my own (I wrote a post on this recently), and I also believe that no one is ever fully happy, all the time. It’s alright to have times where you aren’t particularly happy.

      That doesn’t mean I want to be miserable or anything :), but for me at least I’m willing to let commitment be the higher priority in many/most cases.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Very well said! I think in a marriage “we” is important, but fundamentally you have to take care of “me.”

    Reminds me of that quote, “we accept the love we think we deserve.” If we do not love ourselves, how can we offer love in the relationship?

    Great post!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s